What To Do if You Were Overpaid by the EDD

Being notified by the Employment Development Department (EDD) that you were overpaid benefits can feel like a shock. Whether it happened because of a mistake, a misunderstanding, or something you believe is wrong, the consequences can be serious—including repayment obligations, penalties, collection actions, and even disqualification of future benefits. The good news: you have rights, and you can take meaningful steps to respond and protect your interests. Don’t worry; the guide below details what this means and how to proceed upon receiving such claims. Read the detailed walkthrough below to determine what to do if you were overpaid by the EDD.

Defining Overpayment

First, let’s detail what overpayment means in reference to unemployment insurance and other benefits. Although the definition is simple, the whole topic is a bit more complex. So, let’s discuss how to react when you receive an overpayment notice from EDD.

What is an overpayment?

A benefit overpayment occurs when you collect unemployment, disability, or Paid Family Leave (PFL) benefits you are not eligible to receive. For example, if you receive too much in unemployment insurance payments, that’s considered an overpayment. It is important to repay overpayments to avoid collection and legal action. This may happen if the EDD determines you collected benefits to which you were not entitled.

How the EDD notifies you

When the EDD detects a potential overpayment, it first sends a Notice of Potential Overpayment (often form DE 1447) indicating that the EDD needs more information. For unemployment benefits, you typically must respond within 15 days of mailing. 

If the EDD then concludes you were overpaid, you will receive a Notice of Overpayment (DE 1444) summarizing:

• The total amount due.
• A summary for each week that you were overpaid.
• Information on how to appeal.

Appeal Rights

You have the right to appeal an overpayment determination. To do so, submit your appeal in writing within 30 days of the mailing date listed on the Notice of Overpayment (DE 1444). If more than 30 days have passed, an appeal is still possible—just be sure to explain the reasons for missing the original deadline.An Administrative Law Judge (ALJ) will review your reasons for missing the deadline. If the ALJ decides that you had good cause for missing the appeal deadline, the ALJ will continue to review your appeal. Follow the instructions in your Notice of Overpayment if you want to appeal. 

For more information about appealing an overpayment, see Unemployment Insurance Appeals.

Fraud vs. Non-fraud overpayments

One of the most important distinctions is whether the overpayment is labeled as fraudulent or non-fraudulent:

• Non-fraud: The EDD believes the overpayment was not your fault. You’ll still owe the money, but the rules regarding penalties and offsets differ.
• Fraud: The EDD determined you intentionally misrepresented or withheld facts to receive benefits. In this case, there can be a 30% penalty on top of the overpayment amount, and potential disqualification of benefits for up to 23 weeks.
  

Understanding how the EDD has classified your case is essential—it determines your rights, the strategy you’ll use, and the potential consequences.

Accidental Overpayments

If you accidentally receive benefits that you were not eligible for, you’ll have to return the excess payment to the EDD unless you are eligible for a waiver. That said, before repaying anything, it’s vital to understand that receiving notice of overpayment doesn’t mean you’re receiving more than you should be.

What qualifies as an accidental overpayment?

An accidental overpayment typically means you were paid benefits you weren’t eligible for, but not because you intentionally misled the EDD. Common examples include:

• You forgot to report part-time wages or side income.
• You returned to work but forgot to stop certifying.
• The employer or EDD records had an error, and you responded accordingly.

EDD’s guide “Tips to Avoid UI Payment Delays, Overpayments, and Penalties” shows that you must report wages, work, and other income accurately during certification to avoid overpayment risk.

What to do immediately when you receive notice

On receiving a notice of potential or actual overpayment:

1. Read the letter carefully. Note the amount claimed, weeks involved, and the reason.
2. Check your records. Compare your certifications, wage statements, employer notifications, and last known status changes.
3. Respond on time. For the DE 1447 notice, you typically have 15 days; ignoring it often converts it into a formal overpayment.
4. Consider your options. If you believe the overpayment was not your fault or would cause extraordinary hardship, you may be eligible for a waiver. The EDD states that for waivers you may receive a Personal Financial Statement (DE 1446) to evaluate hardship. 
5. Avoid new claims until resolved. Outstanding overpayments can delay or reduce future benefit payments—the EDD may offset new benefits for repayment. 

Repayment and options

If the overpayment stands and no waiver is approved:

• Visit the EDD’s Benefit Overpayment Services section to manage payments, view past payments, or set up an installment agreement. 
• The EDD may recoup the funds through wage garnishment, withholding tax refunds, lottery prizes, bank levies, or deduction from future benefits.
• For non-fraud cases, the EDD may offset up to 25% of your weekly unemployment or disability benefits.

Overpayment Waiver

If we determine the potential overpayment was not your fault and was not due to fraud, you may qualify for an overpayment waiver. The EDD will send you an Application for Overpayment Waiver (DE 1446UI) with the Notice of Potential Overpayment (DE 1447).You must complete and return the Application for Overpayment Waiver (DE 1446UI) to be considered for a waiver. We will review your information to determine if repaying the overpayment would cause you extraordinary hardship:

• If you qualify for a waiver, The EDD will send you a Notice of Overpayment with the amount that was waived.
• If you do not qualify for a waiver, we will send you a Notice of Overpayment (DE 1444) or a Notice of Denial of Waiver (DE 1445) with a section that explains why you did not receive a waiver.

When to request a waiver

You should ask for a waiver, especially if:

• You accepted benefits in good faith, believing you were eligible.
• You cannot repay without extraordinary hardship (e.g., you would be unable to meet living expenses).
• The overpayment was clearly not your fault (e.g., EDD or employer error).
  

If you receive a waiver denial and believe it was wrong, you have the right to appeal or request reconsideration. The deadline typically is 30 days from the notice mailing date.

Repay Your Overpayment

The EDD will mail you a Benefit Overpayment Collection Notice (DE 8344JUDR) 30 days after we mail a Notice of Overpayment (DE 1444) or Notice of Denial of Benefits and Overpayment (DE 1480), or when an appeal is denied.You cannot repay your overpayment online until you receive a Benefit Overpayment Collection Notice (DE 8344JUDR) with your Claimant ID and Letter ID.

If you do not repay your overpayment on time, the money can be deducted from future unemployment, disability, or Paid Family Leave benefits. Other actions The EDD take includes:

• Withholding your federal and state income tax refunds.
• Withholding your state lottery winnings.
• Withholding other money the state owes you.
• Filing a summary judgment against you in court, which involves additional court costs and interest
• Recording a lien on your property.

Wrongful Overpayment Claims

Now that you know what to do if you were overpaid by the EDD, let’s dive into how to react to a wrongful overpayment claim.

What is a wrongful claim?

Sometimes you may believe the EDD’s overpayment determination is incorrect—or that you weren’t at fault at all. In those cases, you have the opportunity to appeal the decision and present evidence showing:

• You were eligible for the benefits paid.
• Any misreporting was unintentional and without fault.
• The EDD misapplied eligibility rules or misinterpreted your situation.

How to appeal a Notice of Overpayment

According to the EDD’s overpayments and penalties page, you must submit your appeal in writing within 30 days of the mailing date of the Notice of Overpayment (DE 1444). Late appeals may still be allowed if you can show “good cause” for missing the deadline. 

To cover all strategies and defenses in overpayment appeals, see our guide How You Can Appeal an EDD Overpayment

Key steps include:

1. Fill out the appeal form or write a letter stating why you disagree, using the language of your notice.
2. Include all supporting evidence (proof of wages, employer statements, certification logs).
3. Show that any error was not intentional or that it would cause undue hardship to repay.
4. Prepare for a hearing before an Administrative Law Judge (ALJ) if required.

What happens after you appeal?

Once your appeal is filed:

• The EDD may stay collection actions while it is reviewed (but not always).
• You will be scheduled for a hearing where you can present evidence and testimony.
• If the decision is reversed, you may avoid repayment or have the penalty waived.
• If upheld, you will owe the full amount plus interest and penalties. Collection tools may then be used.
  

Key arguments you can use

• Good-faith error: You misunderstood a question, or a wage was mistakenly omitted.
• Employer/EDD error: Your employer misreported wages, or the EDD used wrong information.
• Extraordinary hardship: You provided financial information showing repayment would create untenable hardship (necessary for waiver).
• Lack of intent to defraud: You reported everything honestly to your knowledge and did not withhold information.

Conclusion

It’s understandable to assume, “The EDD is serious business, so if they say I received too much, they must be right.” Sadly, unjustified overpayment claims are not rare occurrences.Therefore, you must always examine whether the amount the EDD claims you were overpaid is accurate, or if you were overpaid at all.

The EDD overpayment lawyers at Pershing Square Law Firm are very familiar with unfortunate situations like this. In addition, appealing these wrongful claims can be a laborious process, particularly to complete novices.For this very reason, overpayment lawyers help people fight unjustified claims, ensuring the process runs smoothly. Hopefully, now that you know the difference between justified and unjustified overpayment claims, you can find a swift solution if you receive a notice in the mail.